Sell My Car Buff
Sell My Car Buff is a car dealer located at 531 Farber Lakes Dr in Williamsville, New York, specializing in vehicle appraisal and purchasing.
Financing not verifiedBHPH Finder score 6.1/10
531 Farber Lakes Dr, Williamsville, NY 14221Published · Details verified

Google rating
4.4 / 5
Reviews
12
Hours today
—
Best for
Individuals looking to sell their vehicles in the Williamsville area.
About Sell My Car Buff
Sell My Car Buff is a car dealer located at 531 Farber Lakes Dr in Williamsville, New York. The business specializes in vehicle acquisition and appraisal services for residents in the Williamsville area. Customers can reach the dealership at 716-210-3501 or through their official website to initiate the selling process.
The dealership offers a streamlined process for individuals looking to sell their vehicles, with some services including home pickup for convenience. While the business operates as a car dealer, individuals should verify specific inventory or financing options directly with the staff, as services can vary based on current appraisal tools and market conditions.
Does Sell My Car Buff offer in-house financing?
Unknown. We could not read the dealer's website (sellmycarbuff.com) to confirm its financing terms; it appears here because Google returns it for buy here pay here searches in Williamsville. Call and ask before visiting.
How BHPH Finder scores Sell My Car Buff: 6.1 out of 10
- Google reputation (4.4 rating, 12 reviews)
- 5.1 / 6
- Has a website we could read
- 1 / 1
- Financing terms not verified
- 0 / 1
- Prints a down payment figure
- 0 / 0.5
- Says it reports payments to credit bureaus
- 0 / 0.5
- Open on Sundays
- 0 / 0.25
- Verified by the owner
- 0 / 0.75
The score weighs Google reputation by review volume (up to 6 points) and adds what the dealer's own website verifiably advertises. It is BHPH Finder's editorial rating, not a customer rating. How it works.
What does Sell My Car Buff offer?
- Vehicle appraisal
- Car buying services
- Vehicle pickup
Why customers choose Sell My Car Buff
Efficient and simple selling process
Inconsistent appraisal offers
- Located at 531 Farber Lakes Dr, Williamsville, NY
- Contact the dealership directly at 716-210-3501
- Offers vehicle appraisal and buying services
- Provides vehicle pickup options for select customers
Where is Sell My Car Buff located?
531 Farber Lakes Dr, Williamsville, NY 14221What do customers say about Sell My Car Buff?
Justin Y. helped me sell my 2013 Hyundai Elantra for a fair price, and the entire process was smooth and stress-free. I would absolutely recommend Sell My Buff/Basil Resale Center to friends and family. A true 10/10 experience.
This was a smooth & easy experience for me! I was able to get a good price for my car & Justin was open & easy to work with I highly recommend you sell your vehicle with him! It’s worth your while!
I had the pleasure of dealing with Justin at Sell My Car Buff. They made the process so simple, they even came to my house to pick the car up! I highly recommend Justin and the team over at Sell My Car Buff if you are looking to sell your car!
Be careful with this place. I answered all the questions on the website about car condition as accurately as I could when I wanted to sell my car and was quoted a price. Once at the dealership I was then given an offer that was less than 20% of the original offer. An example question on the website is they ask if any tires are flat, to which I answered no. They don’t ask about tire condition or tread depth. If they did I would have answered that the tire condition and tread depth was bad. I would have been ok (and went in expecting) to get an actual offer that was 10-15% less than the original quoted offer but to get an offer that was more than 80% less when I answered questions honestly made this a not so fun experience. So, my main issue is that the website should ask better questions so that you get a more accurate initial quote. I would say that Justin was a super friendly guy and I had no issues working with him.
Don't waste your time. I received an offer through their online tool that was $3000 less that what I was offered at CarMax. I told Justin I wasn't interested unless he could beat CarMax's offer, which he told me he could if I could "give him 15 minutes" and brought the car in. Brought the car in for an appraisal, and sat around waiting for half an hour only to be given an offer even lower than what I was quoted online. Go to CarMax - you'll be much better off.
Questions about Sell My Car Buff
Where is Sell My Car Buff located?
Sell My Car Buff is located at 531 Farber Lakes Dr, Williamsville, NY 14221.
How can I contact Sell My Car Buff?
You can contact Sell My Car Buff by calling 716-210-3501 or visiting their website.
Does Sell My Car Buff offer home pickup?
Yes, some customers have reported that Sell My Car Buff provides vehicle pickup services at their homes.



