A-1 Toyota
A-1 Toyota is a New Haven car dealership offering new vehicle sales, professional maintenance, automotive repairs, and car rental services.
Financing not verifiedBHPH Finder score 5.5/10
Open now · closes 7:30 PM50 Amity Rd, New Haven, CT 06515Published · Details verified

Google rating
4.2 / 5
Reviews
1,085
Hours today
8:30 AM – 7:30 PM
Best for
Buyers seeking new Toyota vehicles and professional automotive maintenance services.
About A-1 Toyota
A-1 Toyota is a car dealership located at 50 Amity Rd in New Haven, Connecticut. The business offers new Toyota vehicle sales, routine maintenance, automotive repairs, and car rental services to the local community. Customers can access these services Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 7:30 PM and Saturday from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM.
The dealership provides a professional environment for purchasing vehicles, featuring a no-haggle pricing policy and dedicated sales consultants. In addition to vehicle sales, the facility includes a service department equipped to handle routine maintenance such as oil changes and body repairs. The location also provides amenities for waiting customers, including a cafe.
Does A-1 Toyota offer in-house financing?
Unknown. We could not read the dealer's website (a1toyota.com) to confirm its financing terms; it appears here because Google returns it for buy here pay here searches in New Haven. Call and ask before visiting.
How BHPH Finder scores A-1 Toyota: 5.5 out of 10
- Google reputation (4.2 rating, 1,085 reviews)
- 5 / 6
- Has a website we could read
- 0.5 / 1
- Financing terms not verified
- 0 / 1
- Prints a down payment figure
- 0 / 0.5
- Says it reports payments to credit bureaus
- 0 / 0.5
- Open on Sundays
- 0 / 0.25
- Verified by the owner
- 0 / 0.75
The score weighs Google reputation by review volume (up to 6 points) and adds what the dealer's own website verifiably advertises. It is BHPH Finder's editorial rating, not a customer rating. How it works.
What does A-1 Toyota offer?
- New Toyota sales
- Routine vehicle maintenance
- Automotive repairs
- Car rentals
- Oil changes
Why customers choose A-1 Toyota
No-pressure sales environment
Transparent pricing policy
Helpful service department
- Open six days a week with extended evening hours until 7:30 PM on weekdays
- Offers comprehensive automotive services including repairs and oil changes
- Maintains a no-haggle pricing policy for new vehicle purchases
- Features an on-site cafe for customers waiting during vehicle service
- Provides car rental options for local customers
When is A-1 Toyota open?
| Monday | 8:30 AM – 7:30 PM |
| Tuesday | 8:30 AM – 7:30 PM |
| Wednesday | 8:30 AM – 7:30 PM |
| Thursday | 8:30 AM – 7:30 PM |
| Friday | 8:30 AM – 7:30 PM |
| Saturday | 9:00 AM – 6:00 PM |
| Sunday | Closed |
Where is A-1 Toyota located?
50 Amity Rd, New Haven, CT 06515What do customers say about A-1 Toyota?
I am a very happy customer of A1 Toyota. Whenever my car is due for a routine maintenance and service, I become genuinely excited. The reason is because over the past four years, I have developed a wonderful routine of coming to this A1 Toyota early in the morning, dropping off my car, and going to the Toyota Cafe for a fresh complimentary cup of coffee as I read my Bible or do work. My experience each time has been easy, smooth, and enjoyable. Today, I had my best experience so far – thanks to the exceptional, kind, and customer-centered service of Leonardo Taveras Quezada. From the moment I stepped into the building, Leonardo warmly welcomed me and took car of my car service appointment. He even took the initiative to point to a chart on the wall and advise me to come back when my car hit 25kmiles (and not any more than 26k miles) so that I would be able to take full advantage of Toyota's free car services up until 25,000 miles. I believe that it is the quality service of people like Leonardo that makes this A1 Toyota the best place for anyone in Connecticut to receive car-related services.
I have been buying new cars for over 40 years and this dealership has been the best to date. From my initial contact with James Hollar as the internet sales advisor, then Ugur Akdeniz as the sales consultant and then to Rachel Soto the delivery coordinator, they provided outstanding services and communication throughout the entire experience. The dealership upfront pricing is matched by no other dealership within my 500 mile radius. This family owned dealership is a gem in Connecticut. I think our new car looks great in our garage. Update: A fine example of the professional staff. We ran into a problem getting the permanent tags within the 30 day window due to snow/ice storm which no one can predict. Working with the General Manager Dan Wheeler and the DMV specialist Victoria Felder, they were able to overnight my tags to me in time. They will work with you on all phases of the sale. Cannot say enough good things about this dealership. We really enjoy the car and the sales experience has made it that much better.
I'm way overdue for this, but A1 Toyota was great. The whole experience, from my first steps through the door to the signatures was positive. My sales consultant, Ugur, was fantastic. Very knowledgeable and helpful throughout the process. Their whole team fosters a no-pressure environment. I am very happy with my purchase and their best price no-haggle policy easily beat other Toyota dealerships in the area. They're a fantastic team.
It was a really pleasant experience. They were up front about MSRP pricing and financing, they accepted me declining packages/accessories without needling me. There was no pressure and no haggling. I was prepared for a long, exhausting talk but it was just genuinely nice. Moe was our consultant, he did well even if he's new.
I am writing to share my sincere appreciation for the outstanding service I received at A-1 Toyota this past Saturday afternoon, and specifically for Mark Mastraccio. I arrived unexpectedly after accidentally hitting the side of my garage door and knocking the mirror off my brand-new 2026 Toyota Camry XSE. I was admittedly a bit panicked when I walked in, but Mark immediately stepped in to help... as he always does. Despite it being a busy Saturday afternoon with no appointment, Mark took the time to assist me without hesitation. He promptly located a mechanic (Anthony Montefusco), and together they graciously reattached the mirror for me. Their willingness to help so quickly turned a very stressful moment into a manageable one. Mark or Anthony did not have to stop what he was doing to assist me, yet he did so with professionalism and kindness. I have been a Toyota owner since 2019 and have exclusively serviced my vehicles at A-1 Toyota since then. The consistently high level of customer care I receive is exactly why I remain a loyal customer. Please extend my sincere thanks to Mark and the technician who helped me. Mark’s actions on Saturday are a true reflection of the exceptional service culture at A-1 Toyota. I am very grateful. Sincerely, Mary-Ann
Questions about A-1 Toyota
Does A-1 Toyota offer car rentals?
A-1 Toyota provides car rental services as part of its dealership offerings in New Haven. Customers can inquire directly at the 50 Amity Rd location for specific rental availability.
What are the business hours for A-1 Toyota?
A-1 Toyota is open Monday through Friday from 8:30 AM to 7:30 PM and Saturday from 9:00 AM to 6:00 PM. The dealership is closed on Sundays.
Does A-1 Toyota perform vehicle repairs?
A-1 Toyota maintains a service department that performs routine maintenance and vehicle repairs. Services include oil changes and assistance with body damage.


